Hidden Allergens in Pumpkin Spice
By late September, pumpkin spice isn’t just a flavor — it’s a frenzy. Coffee chains roll out their seasonal lattes, bakeries launch limited-edition muffins, and even breweries lean into cinnamon-and-clove ales. For customers, it’s comfort in a cup. For operators, it’s a revenue wave worth riding. But under the whipped cream and warm nostalgia lurk risks that can turn a cozy fall promotion into a compliance nightmare: hidden allergens.
Pumpkin spice blends themselves are usually just spices, but the products built around them are another story. The latte that sells so well in the morning rush may come with a topping of dairy-based whipped cream, a syrup thickened with soy, or a drizzle that contains tree nut oils. That pumpkin muffin? Almost certainly wheat- and egg-based, maybe with pecans baked in. For customers managing allergies — and there are more than 32 million Americans who do — these seasonal treats can quickly shift from indulgence to emergency. And for operators, one oversight can mean more than a lost customer. It can mean liability, fines, and front-page news.
The Allergen Minefield Behind Fall Favorites
Pumpkin spice menus tend to combine several of the “Big 9” allergens in a single item. A latte may carry milk, soy, and tree nuts depending on the syrup or topping. Baked goods typically bring in wheat, eggs, and dairy. Even gluten-free pumpkin treats aren’t immune: almond flour and cashew butter are often used as substitutes, creating risks for nut-allergic guests.
Cross-contact is where things really spiral. Coffee shops use the same steam wand for dairy and non-dairy drinks unless they deliberately separate equipment. Bakeries may cool pumpkin muffins on the same racks as nut-filled pastries. Seasonal rushes mean staff are moving quickly, and allergen protocols that work in July may slip when pumpkin spice season doubles foot traffic.
The CDC underscores that the Big 9 allergens — milk, eggs, fish, shellfish, peanuts, tree nuts, soy, wheat, and sesame — cause the vast majority of food allergy reactions in the U.S. Pumpkin spice menus check a lot of those boxes, often in combination.
What Operators Need to Do Now
Staying profitable and safe doesn’t mean killing the pumpkin spice menu. It means treating it with the same diligence as the rest of the year — if not more. Audit every new syrup, topping, and premix before launch. Post allergen information clearly, on menus and online, not just when asked. Dedicate tools and utensils to dairy-free or allergen-free prep when possible, and train staff to handle seasonal questions with confidence. Above all, have a plan for what happens if something goes wrong — whether that’s keeping epinephrine on hand where permitted, or making sure staff know how to call for immediate medical help.
Fall is when operators need seasonal staff the most — and that means seasonal training, too. Don’t assume new hires know how to handle allergens. Bake it into orientation so that every pumpkin spice latte or muffin sold comes with the assurance of safety.
Checkout our resource center for valuable downloads
Final Word
Pumpkin spice has become a symbol of comfort — a taste that marks the shift into autumn. But for the millions living with food allergies, comfort can quickly become crisis if operators aren’t vigilant. By taking allergens seriously, labeling clearly, and training staff, businesses can keep the season festive and profitable without putting anyone at risk. The only thing your guests should worry about this fall is whether to order that second latte — not whether the first will send them to the ER.
